1. What is the main idea of the reading?
2. Who is the audience for the reading?
3. What is the author's purpose for writing about this topicThe subject of a reading. ?
4. What is the author's opinion about the topic?
5. Do you agree or disagree with the author?
6. Why do you agree or disagree with the author?
7. What can you bring to the discussion about this topic?
These questions are important because they allow you to: 1) break down the reading's content, 2) understand what the author thinks and is trying to accomplish in the reading, and 3) begin to formulate an opinion about the reading's contentThe text in a writing that includes facts, thoughts, and ideas. The information that forms the body of the work..
Once you have answered the seven questions about the reading, you can take your responses and turn them into a response paragraph. Start by writing a very short summaryA brief restatement of an author’s main idea and major supporting details. Summaries are factual and should be written in the third-person with an objective point of view. of the reading, noting the main idea, purpose, and author's opinion. You can use the answers to the first four questions to help you write this part of the response. You should also include the titleThe name that identifies a work. Example: The Old Man and The Sea is the title of a book by Earnest Hemingway. and author, if available. After you address the author's point of viewThe perspective from which an author considers a subject or issue., finish by providing your opinion of the piece, which will be the answers to the last three questions.
To be considered a professional, you must be able to understand the opinions of others and respond to them. For example, as a student, you will engage in classroom conversations with your classmates and professors about issues related to the course. Often, your discussions may be focused on a topic you read about for class. In order to respond to the topic and share your opinion, you need to have read and understood the reading assignment. From there, you can begin thinking critically about whether you agree or disagree with the author and begin forming your own opinions about the topic. When you can share these opinions with others, you are on your way to becoming a better student and a professional.
Read the passageA short portion of a writing taken from a larger source, such as a book, article, speech, or poem. and then view some sample answers to the seven key questions. Then read the example student response to the reading.
Community College or University: A Win-Win Career Choice
When choosing whether to attend a community college or a university, you must think carefully about the career you want. At a community college, you can choose from many types of technical programs, such as welding, nursing, photography, and graphic design, but you can also choose a liberal arts program, too. Many programs at community colleges have certificates or degrees that you can complete in one or two years, which means you can be out of school sooner, starting your career, and making money.
If you are thinking about a different type of career, a university may be right for you. At universities, you can choose to major in Physics, Engineering, Theater, Education, and Business, among many other options as well. Within these majors, you can even specialize further. For example, if you want to major in Engineering, you might choose to specialize in mechanical engineering, electrical engineering, or even aerospace engineering. One item to consider is that if you choose to attend a university, you may be in college longer, as most majors require at least four years of study. If you choose to attend a community college, you have many career options to choose from, but you will have many options at a university as well. In the end, you should think about what careers you are interested in and then explore your options for moving forward. Take your time and don't rush; it's not a decision you should make quickly. Remember, now is an exciting time in your life, so choose the college that will be a good fit for you!
1. What is the main idea of the reading?
Choosing whether to attend a community college or a university based on the career you want.
2. Who is the audience for the reading?
Students who are deciding which one to attend.
3. What is the author's purpose for writing about this topic?
To inform the student of the similarities and differences between the two and help the student make a decision.
4. What is the author's opinion about the topic?
Neutral. The author does not present a clear opinion about one or the other. Instead, the author encourages the readers to consider which is best for them.
5. Do you agree or disagree with the author?
I agree with the author that it is very important for students to take their time and really think about which college is right for them.
6. Why do you agree or disagree with the author?
I have struggled with whether to attend a community college or a university. I want to go into the field of nursing, but I am not sure if I want to get my LPN or RN, which I can do at community college, or if I want to get my BSN which I can only get at a university.
7. What can you bring to the discussion about this topic?
I have been researching nursing programs to learn more about what I am interested in. I think I want to work in a doctor's office helping families, so learning about family medicine and working in an office would be good for me. I may want to go on for more education too, like a Master's degree in nursing, so that is also a factor in making my decision. After doing more research on this topic, I can share what I have found with others who might be in a similar situation.
Below is an example of how a student has responded to the reading by including a summary of the topic and then adding her opinion.
The reading titled, "Community College or University: A Win-Win Career Choice" explains to the reader how the two places offer different career options. The author tried to balance the points about the two options and did not come out and say one is a better choice than the other. However, the author did encourage the readers to take their time when making a decision about which type of college to attend. I agree with the author about the importance of really thinking about what a person wants before selecting a college. I have been doing research on the career I am interested in, which is nursing. I know that there are different types of nurses, different types of degrees one can get as a nurse, and different options for where nurses can work. I have learned that I can become a nurse by attending either a community college or a university since both have programs in nursing. Every person thinking about college should really think about what interests them so they make the right choice.
Read the following passage. Then respond to the questions that follow and use your answers to write a brief response.
Changing Climate, Changing World
Climate change has become a topic of debate among scientists and the general public. For years, many scientists have emphasized the need to do something about the negative effects that carbon dioxide emissions are having on global warming and our changing climate. Recently, this has emerged again in the news, showing that our reliance on fossil fuels is hurting us more than we know.
According to Vastag and Samenow, authors of an article on WashingtonPost.com titled, "Carbon Dioxide Levels Hit Troubling Milestone, Scientists Say," recent levels of the gas have reached a point not seen in millions of years. The rise in these levels indicates our dependence on fossil fuels is damaging our environment and something must be done.
1. What is the main idea of the reading?
The rise in carbon dioxide levels is harming the environment.
2. Who is the audience for the reading?
Readers who are interested in and/or concerned about global warming
3. What is the author's purpose for writing about this topic?
To inform readers about the rise in carbon dioxide levels and convince them that something must be done
4. What is the author's opinion about the topic?
The author believes these rising levels are contributing to global warming and, therefore, changes must be made to stop this from happening.
5. Do you agree or disagree with the author?
6. Why do you agree or disagree with the author?
I think our climate is definitely changing, and I believe this is shown in the extreme weather events we’ve seen around the world recently.
7. What can you bring to the discussion about this topic?
I can share examples about the tornadoes and floods that have been happening in my hometown. The number of each type of event has grown just in the past five years. I could look up statistics to prove this if needed.
Now, use your responses to these questions to write a one-paragraph response to the reading. Be sure to include the title, topic, purpose, and author's opinion, and then express your personal opinion on the reading and subject.
The passage titled, "Changing Climate, Changing World" describes the recent rise in carbon dioxide levels, which is contributing to global warming. The purpose of the reading is to inform readers about this new information and express how changes need to be made to our use of fossil fuels. I agree with the author that this has become a major problem for our world. Our climate is definitely changing, and this is obvious in the extreme weather we've seen in recent years. In my own hometown, I have seen damage caused by floods and tornadoes many times, even in just the past few years. These events show that something is changing in our world, and I agree that the rise in carbon dioxide levels could certainly be contributing to it.
What did you learn about responding to a reading that was new or different from what you knew before reading this?
I learned that responding to a reading meant that I should also provide a short summary of the reading before I add my opinion about it. Before that, I was used to just writing my thoughts.
How is responding to a reading a skill that will be useful to you in your future?
I can see different ways that responding to a reading will be useful to me in the future. In school, I will need to read and think critically about sources of information. I will have to write research papers where I will need to state what someone else thought and then add my own thoughts. In my future job as a history teacher, I will be reading many different books and articles about various events that happened in the past. When I teach these events to the students, I need to help them see how different authors may have a certain opinion that is reflected in how they describe events. This will help us have better class discussions and will help me become a more critical reader and thinker.